Condition is the most argued about, least standardized part of reselling sneakers and streetwear. Two sellers can describe the same pair as deadstock and used, and both can believe they are being honest. The buyer, meanwhile, has their own definition, and when those definitions collide you get returns, partial refunds and feedback you did not deserve.

Condition grading is not a formality. It is a pricing tool. The gap between deadstock and very near deadstock can be 20 percent of your payout, and the gap between very near deadstock and used can be double that. This guide gives you a working grading system, the photo standards to back it up, and the description language that stops disputes before they start.

The Grades and What They Actually Mean

Deadstock, usually written DS, means brand new and never worn. No creasing anywhere, clean soles with no wear pattern, original laces and inserts present, and the original box in reasonable shape. Tried on once in the house on carpet is still a gray area for many buyers, so if the toe box has any crease at all, it is not deadstock.

Very near deadstock, or VNDS, means worn very lightly, typically one to three wears, with no visible damage but not perfect. Faint toe creasing, soles that are clean but no longer factory white on the tread contact points, no scuffs, no discoloration. Some sellers write PADS, which means passes as deadstock, meaning it looks new in hand.

Used in good condition means clearly worn but well cared for. Visible creasing, some sole wear, maybe minor scuffing, but no structural issues, no yellowing on clear soles, no heel drag, no odor.

Used in fair condition means heavier wear. Significant creasing, noticeable sole wear, possible scuffs or small marks, midsole discoloration. Still wearable and honest, just no longer premium.

Beat means heavily worn. Sole wear through the tread in places, heel drag, paint loss, or repairs. These still sell, especially in rare colorways, but only when priced and photographed accordingly.

Each step down the grading scale has a predictable effect on payout. Grade honestly and price to the grade.

What Each Grade Costs You

Using a hypothetical 300 deadstock market price as the baseline, here is roughly how the market discounts each step, though it varies by model and rarity.

VNDS typically sells for 80 to 90 percent of deadstock. Used in good condition tends to land at 60 to 75 percent. Used in fair condition is often 40 to 55 percent. Beat pairs can be anywhere from 20 to 40 percent, and for common models they may not be worth the shipping cost.

Two important exceptions. Rare and discontinued models hold value much better in worn condition, because there is no deadstock supply available at any price. And models with known aging problems, such as yellowing soles or crumbling midsoles, get discounted harder in used condition than the general pattern suggests.

The practical use of this table is at the buying end, not the selling end. When you are sourcing, you should be applying these discounts to your offer automatically. Paying a deadstock price for a VNDS pair is one of the most common ways resellers lose money without noticing.

How Platforms Treat Condition Differently

Marketplaces that authenticate, like StockX, enforce strict condition standards. Deadstock means deadstock, box included, and a pair that has been tried on can fail verification. That is a real cost: return shipping, a cancelled sale and sometimes a seller penalty. If a pair is anything less than truly new, do not list it as new on an authenticated platform.

Listing marketplaces like Grailed, eBay, Mercari and Poshmark let you describe condition yourself, which gives you flexibility and puts the responsibility on your description. Here your protection is documentation, not the platform.

Shopify or your own storefront gives you total control, which means you should publish your own grading definitions on the site. Buyers cannot dispute a standard they read before purchasing.

The Photo Standard That Prevents Disputes

Almost every condition dispute traces back to a photo the seller did not take. The fix is a fixed shot list you run for every single item, no exceptions.

Shoot both shoes together from the side, then each shoe individually from the side to show creasing. Shoot straight down at the toe boxes, because that is where creasing shows most and where buyers look first. Shoot both soles flat to show tread wear. Shoot the heels, including the heel counter and any drag. Shoot the insoles, which reveal actual wear more honestly than anything else. Shoot the inside of the collar. Shoot the box, including the label. And shoot every flaw individually, close up, with something for scale.

Use natural light or consistent artificial light, and never edit condition out of a photo. Brightening an image so a scuff disappears is how you turn a fair sale into a return.

The counterintuitive part is that photographing flaws clearly increases your sale price. Buyers pay more when they trust the listing, and nothing builds trust like a seller who shows the worst angle voluntarily.

Description Language That Holds Up

Your description should state the grade, then justify it, then disclose everything. A structure that works every time:

Start with the grade and wear count. For example, VNDS, worn twice indoors. Then list what is included: original box, extra laces, hang tag, receipt. Then describe condition part by part: upper, toe box, midsole, outsole, insole, heel. Then a dedicated flaws section, even if it says no flaws beyond light creasing shown in photos.

Avoid the words that cause trouble. Mint, perfect, like new and 9 out of 10 all mean different things to different people. Replace them with specifics. Instead of nearly perfect, write faint toe crease on the left shoe, soles clean with light wear on the tread edge.

One more rule: never describe condition you have not verified in hand. If you are selling something you have not physically inspected, say so or do not sell it.

Run the same shot list on every item. Consistency is what makes your grading credible.

Grading Streetwear and Apparel

Sneaker grading gets all the attention, but apparel needs the same discipline with different checkpoints.

For tees and hoodies, check for pilling, cracking on prints, pit staining, collar stretch, fading and any holes. For denim, check the crotch and inner thigh for wear, the hems, the knees and the pocket bags. For outerwear, check the zipper function, the lining, the cuffs and the collar. For designer pieces, check hardware, stitching and any repairs, and photograph all tags and codes.

Use the same tiered language: new with tags, new without tags, excellent, good, fair. And measure everything. Chest, length, shoulders, sleeve, waist, inseam. Half of all apparel returns are fit issues disguised as condition complaints, and measurements eliminate them.

Handling Condition Disputes When They Happen

Even with good process you will occasionally get a buyer who claims an item is worse than described. Handle it in this order.

Ask for photos of the specific issue. Compare them to your own listing photos, which you kept, because you keep every listing photo. If your photos clearly show the item as described, respond politely with the relevant images and the line from your description. If the buyer has a legitimate point, resolve it fast with a partial refund or a return, because one bad review costs more than one refund.

Then log it. Track which categories and which grades generate disputes for you. If a pattern appears, your grading in that category is too generous and needs tightening.

Making Grading Part of Your Intake Process

Grade at intake, not at listing time. The moment an item enters your inventory, inspect it, assign a grade, note the flaws and record it. Then your listing is just a matter of pulling that information, and your pricing is anchored to a grade you assigned when you were being objective rather than when you were hoping for a higher sale.

Store the grade and flaw notes with the item record so that when you cross-list to five marketplaces you are copying identical condition information everywhere. Inconsistent condition descriptions across platforms is a genuine liability, because a buyer who sees your eBay listing describe the same pair differently from your Grailed listing has a screenshot and a case.

Do this consistently and condition stops being a source of anxiety. You price accurately, you disclose fully, your returns drop, and buyers who have been burned elsewhere start coming back to you specifically because your listings tell the truth.

Grading Consistency Across Your Whole Catalog

Individual accurate grades are good. Consistent grades across hundreds of items are what actually build a reputation. Buyers who purchase from you twice notice whether your definition of good condition held steady, and repeat buyers are the cheapest sales you will ever make.

Write your grading definitions down once and keep them where you do intake. Not in your head, because your standards will drift depending on how badly you want to sell something. Review a random sample of your live listings every month against those definitions and correct anything that has crept.

If you have help photographing or listing, this becomes non-negotiable. Two people grading by feel will produce two different catalogs under one seller name, and the returns will show up in your numbers before you figure out why.

Keep grades, flaw notes and photos attached to every item across every marketplace. Get started with TracknList and list with confidence.