Every reseller has seen it. You list a pair of sneakers for $180 and within an hour someone sends an offer for $60. It happens on every platform, in every category, at every price point. Lowball offers are part of the game, and how you handle them can be the difference between making more sales and leaving money on the table.
Most resellers fall into one of two camps. They either ignore every offer below their asking price, or they get frustrated and fire back with a rude message. Both approaches cost you money. The first leaves potential deals on the floor. The second burns bridges with buyers who might have come up to a reasonable price with the right response.
There is a better way to handle negotiations that protects your margins and closes more sales. Here is how to do it.
Why Buyers Send Lowball Offers
Before you get annoyed at a low offer, it helps to understand why buyers do it. Most of the time, it is not personal and it is not disrespectful. They are just testing the water.
Some buyers have been trained by platforms like Poshmark and Mercari where negotiation is built into the culture. They expect to go back and forth. Sending a low first offer is their opening move, not their final number.
Other buyers genuinely do not know the market value of what you are selling. They see a listing, they want the item, and they throw out a number based on what they are willing to spend rather than what the item is worth. This is especially common with casual buyers who are not collectors or resellers themselves.
Then there are the deal hunters. These buyers scroll through listings looking for sellers who are desperate or who have had items sitting for a long time. They know that a seller who has been holding an item for 60 days might accept a lower price just to move it. And honestly, sometimes they are right.
Understanding the motivation behind a low offer helps you respond strategically instead of emotionally.
The Counter-Offer Strategy That Works
The single most effective way to handle a lowball offer is a counter-offer that splits the difference but stays closer to your asking price. This does two important things: it shows the buyer you are willing to negotiate, and it anchors the conversation closer to your number.
Here is the formula. If someone offers 50% or less of your asking price, counter at 10-15% below your listed price. If they offer 50-75% of your asking price, counter at 5-10% below. If they are within 80% of your asking price, you are already in a deal and should close it quickly.
For example, say you have a jacket listed at $120. Someone offers $50. Your counter should be around $105. That might seem like a big gap, but it sends a clear signal about your price floor. Many buyers will come back with $80-90, and now you are in a real negotiation.
The key is responding quickly. The faster you counter, the more likely the buyer is still engaged and still looking at your listing. Wait a day and they have probably moved on or bought something else.
What to say in a message: Keep it simple and friendly. "Thanks for the offer! I can come down to $105 on this one. Let me know if that works for you." No excuses, no explanations about why the item is worth more. Just a clear counter with a positive tone.
When to Accept a Lower Price
Not every item deserves a hard negotiation. Sometimes taking a lower offer is the smarter business move, and knowing when to be flexible is just as important as knowing when to hold firm.
Accept lower offers when the item has been listed for more than 30 days without serious interest. If nobody else is biting at your price, the market is telling you something. A bird in the hand is worth more than a hypothetical full-price buyer who may never come.
Accept when you need to free up capital for better inventory. If you have $200 tied up in a slow-moving item and there is a sourcing opportunity that could return 3x, taking $20 less on the slow item to fund the better buy is the right call every time.
Accept when the buyer is purchasing multiple items. A buyer who wants two or three things from your closet at a slight discount per item is more valuable than three separate full-price sales because you save on shipping materials, time, and platform fees. Bundle deals are almost always worth the discount.
Hold firm when you know the item is priced at or below market value. If comps on eBay show your item selling at your asking price or higher, there is no reason to come down. Someone will pay your price. It just might take a few more days.
Using the Offer Feature Proactively
Most resellers think of offers as something buyers send to them. But flipping the script and sending offers to potential buyers is one of the most underused tactics in reselling.
On eBay, the "Send Offers to Interested Buyers" feature lets you target people who have watched your listing or added it to their cart. These are warm leads. They already want your item but something stopped them from buying, usually the price. Sending a 5-10% discount offer to watchers converts at a surprisingly high rate.
On Poshmark, the "Offer to Likers" feature does the same thing. When someone likes your listing, send them a private offer with a small discount and reduced shipping. Poshmark even lets you do this in bulk, so you can send offers to likers across your entire closet in a few minutes.
On Mercari, promoting your listing with a price drop notifies everyone who liked or saved it. Even a $5 drop can trigger a notification that brings a buyer back to complete the purchase.
The point is that you do not have to wait for buyers to come to you. Proactive offers put you in control of the negotiation and often close deals faster than waiting for organic sales.
Responding to "What's Your Lowest?"
This is the most common message resellers get, and it is also the most mishandled. When a buyer asks "what's your lowest?" they are not trying to lowball you. They are signaling that they want to buy but want to feel like they got a deal.
Never respond with your actual lowest price. If you say "$90" when you would go as low as $80, you have lost all room to negotiate. Instead, respond with something slightly below your asking price and let the negotiation play out.
Try this: "I can do $X shipped. Does that work for you?" Pick a number that is 5-10% below your listing price. This gives the buyer a sense that they are getting a deal, gives you room to come down slightly more if needed, and moves the conversation toward a close instead of an open-ended back and forth.
Another strong response: "I'm flexible on this one. What price were you thinking?" This flips the question back to the buyer and lets them anchor first. If they come in reasonable, you can close the deal immediately. If they lowball, you counter without having shown your cards.
Platform-Specific Negotiation Tips
eBay: Best Offer listings get significantly more views and watchers than fixed-price listings. Even if you do not want to negotiate, enabling Best Offer with an auto-decline minimum (say, 80% of your price) increases visibility while filtering out the extreme lowballers automatically.
Poshmark: The offer system is private, so buyers feel more comfortable negotiating. Use this to your advantage. Price your items 15-20% higher than your target sell price, knowing that most Poshmark buyers expect to negotiate down.
Mercari: Buyers can see your lowest promoted price in the listing history. Be strategic about when you drop prices. If you plan to negotiate, do not promote a price drop first because the buyer will use that lower number as their starting point.
Grailed: Grailed buyers tend to be knowledgeable about market value. Low offers on Grailed are less common but when they happen, a firm but polite counter works well because buyers on the platform generally know what things are worth.
StockX: StockX operates on a bid/ask system, so traditional negotiation does not apply. However, you can use the bid data to inform your pricing on other platforms. If the highest bid on StockX for a shoe is $200, you know there are buyers at that price point, which strengthens your position when negotiating on eBay or Grailed.
The Mental Game of Negotiation
The biggest mistake resellers make with offers is taking them personally. A low offer is not an insult to your item, your pricing, or your business. It is just part of selling. The sooner you can separate emotion from negotiation, the more money you will make.
Think of it this way: every offer is a buyer raising their hand and saying "I want to buy from you." Your job is to find a price that works for both of you. Sometimes that happens. Sometimes it does not. But getting frustrated or ignoring offers altogether means you are turning away people who wanted to give you money.
Track your negotiation results over time. Note how often counter-offers lead to sales, what discount percentage buyers typically accept, and which items generate the most offers. This data helps you price smarter in the future and negotiate from a position of knowledge instead of guessing.
The resellers who close the most deals are not the ones with the lowest prices. They are the ones who respond fast, stay professional, and treat every offer as a potential sale waiting to happen.
Stop guessing on pricing and start making smarter selling decisions. Get started with TracknList and take control of your reselling business.